Your Summer Reviews Are Going Stale

Customers read reviews by date, and for a seasonal business the freshest ones come from the last visits of the year

Your Summer Reviews Are Going Stale

Here's Issue 5 of Local Service Advice. This one's about reviews, and why the ones you earned this summer won't do much for you by spring.

FYI: The partners in here sell tools that work for businesses like yours, at prices that make sense. I only suggest the ones that make a difference to your bottom line. If you buy through one of the links, they give me a cut. That's how this newsletter stays free. Forever.

Thanks and see you next week.

This week: why the date on your reviews matters as much as the count, and how to ask at the last visits of the year. Also, a review-request text you can borrow, and a texting rule that changes on November 25.

Your Summer Reviews Are Going Stale

Every year, BrightLocal surveys American adults about how they use online reviews to pick a local business. The 2026 survey, published in February, went to 1,002 people. Almost all of them, 97%, read reviews for local businesses. That part isn't news.

What should get your attention is how they read them.

They read by date

74% of consumers in the survey look for reviews written in the last three months. Some are stricter than that: 32% look for reviews from the last two weeks, and 18% are only swayed by reviews from the last week.

Think about what that means for a seasonal business. If most of your jobs happen between April and October, so do most of your reviews. The homeowner picking a lawn company, a pool service or a pest company in March is looking at reviews from December, January and February. For a lot of you, those are the three quietest months of the year.

So the reviews you earned in July, however good they were, will be most of a year old by the time that customer is shopping.

They count

47% of consumers say they won't use a business with fewer than 20 reviews. Only 9% will use one with five or fewer. And 68% will only use a business rated four stars or higher.

If you have 12 reviews, you're already off the list for almost half the people looking.

Your competitors are asking

78% of the people in the survey were asked to write a review in the last 12 months. Somebody is asking your customers. If it isn't you, you're competing against companies that do.

They read your replies

89% of consumers expect business owners to respond to reviews, and 81% expect a response within a week. A reply is also the cheapest thing on this list. It takes a minute, and it shows the next person reading that someone's paying attention.

What to do this month

Ask at the last visit. The end of the season is the best time to ask, because the work is fresh and the customer is thinking about you anyway. A short text the same day works best; there's one you can borrow in the next section.

Spread the asks out. Don't send the request to your whole list in one week. Ask as each last visit happens, through November and into December. Reviews that come in over several weeks keep you inside that three-month window longer into the winter.

If you work year-round, keep going. Commercial cleaning, septic and drain, and anyone with winter work doesn't have the same gap. But the three-month window still applies. A steady trickle beats a burst every spring.

Answer every review, good or bad. Within a week, in your own words.

The rule you can't break

Since October 21, 2024, the Federal Trade Commission's rule on reviews has been in force. You can ask for reviews, and you can ask everyone. What you can't do is offer anything in exchange for a positive review, or tie an incentive to what the customer says. "Leave us a five-star review and get $20 off" breaks the rule. The FTC can seek civil penalties of more than $50,000 per violation. A plain request for an honest review is fine.

From this week's partnersAWeber Free: email marketing for free, no credit card required
## Recipe Card: The Review Text

Send it the same day as the last visit of the season, while the work is fresh.

"Hi [Name], it's [your name] from [Company]. Thanks for having us out this season. If you have a minute, would you leave us a review? It helps other people in [town] find us. [link] Reply STOP to opt out."

A few notes on why it's written this way.

It asks for a review, not a five-star review. That's on purpose; see the FTC rule above.

The link goes straight to the place you want reviews, usually your Google Business Profile. The fewer taps, the better.

One reminder a few days later is fine. After that, let it go.

And "Reply STOP to opt out" earns its place at the end of every text you send. The next section explains why.

The Texting Rule That Changes November 25

On September 30, the Federal Communications Commission adopted new rules on how businesses handle people who ask to stop getting calls and texts. They take effect on Wednesday, November 25. That's two days before Black Friday, which is exactly when a lot of you will be sending promotions.

Here's what changes.

Marketing texts and reminders are treated differently. If someone opts out in reply to a marketing text, that opt-out covers all your future marketing calls and texts. If they opt out in reply to an informational message, like an appointment reminder or a payment notice, it only covers that kind of informational message.

You can choose how people opt out. A business can name one method as the way to opt out, such as replying to a text with a standard word, and then it only has to process opt-outs that come in that way. If you pick reply text, you have to accept all seven standard words: stop, quit, end, revoke, opt out, cancel and unsubscribe. And you have to say how to opt out in every message. For a text, "Reply STOP to opt out" does it. If you don't name a method, you still have to honor any reasonable way someone tells you to stop.

You have ten business days. Opt-outs have to be honored within a reasonable time, and no more than ten business days.

Three things to do before the holiday promotions go out:

  • Keep your promotions and your reminders separate, so you know which kind of message each opt-out applies to.
  • Put "Reply STOP to opt out" at the end of every text.
  • Check that your texting system catches all seven words, and that opt-outs actually stop the texts.

That last one is where a texting platform earns its keep. SlickText, for example, has a feature it calls Opt-Out Intelligence that reads incoming replies to catch people who want to opt out but don't use the exact keyword. Its plans start at $29 a month for 500 texts.

If you text a lot of customers, it's worth ten minutes with whoever set up your system to make sure it's ready by the 25th.

This week's featured partner: NiceJob

The hard part of reviews isn't writing the ask. It's remembering to send it after every job, on the day you finish, for the whole season.

NiceJob does that part. It sends the review request by text and email when a job is done, follows up with reminders, and stops once the customer leaves a review. It also keeps an eye on your reviews across the web, so you can answer them in one place. That covers asking at the last visit, spreading the asks out and replying within the week, without you keeping a list.

Plans start at $75 a month, and there's a 14-day free trial that doesn't need a credit card.

Start a NiceJob trial

Here's to one more client this week.

R.J.

Ask R.J. Have a question about getting or keeping customers? Email me at [email protected]. I'm collecting questions for a future advice column.

References

  • BrightLocal, "Local Consumer Review Survey 2026," February 11, 2026. Survey of 1,002 US adults. brightlocal.com
  • Federal Trade Commission, "Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials," Federal Register, August 22, 2024, effective October 21, 2024. govinfo.gov
  • Morgan Lewis, "FTC Issues Final Rule on Consumer Reviews and Testimonials," August 2024. morganlewis.com
  • Nelson Mullins, "FCC Adopts Overhaul of TCPA Consent Revocation Rules," November 2, 2026. nelsonmullins.com
  • Manatt, "FCC Replaces 'Revoke All' Rule and Permits Callers to Designate an Exclusive Revocation Method," October 2026. manatt.com
  • SlickText Help Center, "Tools to help you stay compliant." help.slicktext.com
  • SlickText pricing, Capterra listing. capterra.com
  • NiceJob, product information page. get.nicejob.com
  • NiceJob pricing, Capterra listing. capterra.com
  • Dupple, "NiceJob Review 2026," pricing checked September 2026. dupple.com

Want more like this every week?

One email, every Tuesday at 6 AM. Strategies, case studies, and tools for growing your local service business.